How The Modern Proper Built a Brand That’s Bigger Than Its Founders


This episode is sponsored by Clariti.

Welcome to episode 595 of The Food Blogger Pro Podcast! This week on the podcast, Bjork interviews Holly Erickson and Natalie Mortimer from The Modern Proper.

Holly Erickson and Natalie Mortimer started out with their own food blogs and a catering business they ran together. In 2013, they teamed up to launch The Modern Proper, partly to keep each other accountable and consistent. When Instagram took off for them in 2016, the brand really started to grow. Today, they run a business with a team that includes a writer, a project manager, a photographer, and a recipe developer.

In this interview, Holly and Natalie share what they’ve learned from working as business partners for over a decade, why their first hire was a writer, and what it’s like working with an executive strategy consultant. They also talk about letting go of some of the mental load, how they deal with negative comments, and why they launched Weeknight Dinner Club on Substack, which has grown to 90,000 subscribers. This is a great listen for anyone thinking about a brand beyond their blog, or looking for a new way for readers to find them.

​See the show notes to find relevant links and/or leave a comment!

Three episode takeaways:

  • Why they built a new discovery path on Substack — Holly and Natalie launched Weeknight Dinner Club, a Substack that sits alongside The Modern Proper brand, so they could share more creative recipes that aren’t driven by keywords. They talk about how their voice and recipes differ on Substack, how the newsletter is evolving, what growth has looked like as it reached 90,000 subscribers, how social media turns followers into subscribers, and why getting people to upgrade to paid is so hard.
  • How a distinct brand voice gives you freedom to grow — By defining The Modern Proper’s voice and brand clearly, Holly and Natalie have been able to hire people who create content that still sounds like them. That has helped them let go of some of the mental load that comes with running the business.
  • What it’s like working with an executive strategy consultant — They explain why they brought on a consultant, how that person helps them choose the right KPIs to focus on, and how they get support with work-life balance as two business partners.

Remember to subscribe so you never miss an episode! Please leave a rating or review if you enjoyed listening. 🎧

Thank you to our sponsors!

Optimize your blog content with Clariti.

Clariti is a content organization and optimization platform that helps you uncover SEO insights and monitor performance improvements by analyzing your WordPress and Google data in real-time — so you can audit your content, understand performance, and see real opportunities instead of guessing.

Go to clariti.com to learn more.

And, if you’re a Mediavine publisher, Clariti has a dedicated partnership just for you. Just go to clariti.com/mediavine to see what’s included.

​

Food Blogger Pro

We help creative foodies (like you!) take the guesswork out of building a food blog to share your passion and earn money doing what you love. Join the over 11,000 subscribers on our newsletter to get actionable tips and strategies delivered to your inbox each week! 📫

Read more from Food Blogger Pro
Graphic titled "Four moves after the traffic drop," labeled "Dahn's strategies." Four numbered columns: 01, give readers more reasons to come back; 02, diversify without trying to be everywhere; 03, look beyond the biggest traffic numbers; 04, decide what

This newsletter is sponsored by Yoast. The biggest sale of the year is almost here!Every recipe you publish is a chance for a hungry reader to find you. Yoast SEO Premium helps you make the most of each one, with real-time guidance as you write, so search engines understand your content, and readers get exactly what they came for.The Yoast Black Friday sale is just around the corner. It’s the ideal moment to give your food blog more SEO tools, from AI that drafts titles and meta descriptions...

Tired of receiving AI-focused emails? Click here to receive less. This episode is sponsored by Yoast. Welcome to episode 597 of The Food Blogger Pro Podcast! This week, Bjork is back with part two of our Yoast mini-series — this time chatting with Alex Moss from Yoast. Alex Moss has worked in SEO for 15 years, and he’s seen plenty of change in that time, especially in the last few years. In this interview, he talks with Bjork about what’s different in search today, what has stayed the same,...

We're excited to send new Food Blogger Pro blog posts to you via email! We'll share our latest and greatest blog posts with you where we'll talk about tips and strategies for growing your audience, creating great food content, and monetizing your blog, as well as updates on new courses available for Food Blogger Pro members! Updated Course: Kit Published on November 12, 2026 Oh hey, friends! 👋 We have some exciting news to share: our updated Kit course is officially live! 🎉 If you’ve been...